Tools

Senate Endorses Medical Marijuana Repeal

By Kacey Drescher

After a super-majority failed to advance the “Thera-Juana” bill before a revenue transmittal deadline, the fate of reform lies in the hands of the House, enthusiastic on repeal and following a successful blast motion Wednesday that repeal hit the Senate floor for a debate Thursday evening.

About 24 hours ago, senators were casting their vote for regulation’s last hope. “I’ve heard it said here tonight that we shouldn’t play games, well I would like to know what happened yesterday if that wasn’t games,” says Senator Taylor Brown (R – Senate District 22.) Republicans voiced disappointment with their Democrat counter-parts after Senator Essmann's Senate Bill 423 passed it's second reading 37 to 13 Wednesday morning, but since the Republicans wouldn't "bargain" with the Democrats, the Democrats did not give them the two-thirds vote they needed to advance the regulation measure.

In what can only be described as one of the most heated political spats this session, lawmakers sounded off on the repeal of medical marijuana.

“You go up to your caucus and talk about the 28 to 22 and give yourselves high-fives I understand that… and you can continue to do it to us but sometimes on these important issues we do need to talk and it’s not happening…Repeal isn’t the way to go. Senator Essmann, you do have a good bill but you could have talked to us and you won’t,” says Senator Jim Keane (D – Senate District 38.)

“How dare you say that for people that have MS, Lou Gehrig's disease and a whole host of other maladies that have chosen not to be addicted to narcotics,” says Senator David Wanzenried (D – Senate District 49.)

With the clock ticking and a murky future ahead in the House for the Senate’s regulation measure, some senators support repeal because they say they have no other choice. “I can’t accept status quo when 30,000 people are out there and a lot of them are using medicine Senator Erickson but a lot of them are just smoking pot,” says Senator Art Wittich (R – Senate District 35.)

But that pot, according to senators against House Bill 161, is making a difference in people’s lives. “To take it away from them because some other people are misbehaving is very cruel and very immoral... and I will continue to try and defend those who are not hurting anybody. They’re using the product in the privacy of their home their neighbors in most cases don’t even know they’re doing it but they are getting great relief from it,” says Senator Terry Murphy (R- Senate District 39.)

And while those in opposition say the voters are the only ones who should repeal the state’s marijuana law, supporters say the voters got it wrong. “Sometimes the most compassionate answer you can give is no,” says Senator Rowlie Hutton (R - Senate District 17.) The Montana Medical Marijuana Act passed a 2004 voter's initiative with over 60%.

After over an hour of heated debate “…with 29 senators having voted ay and 21 senators having voted no House Bill 161 has passed second reading.”

Despite clearing an initial hurdle, many legislators are worried that the Governor will veto the repeal measure if it gets to his desk. Schweitzer has said in the past that he believes the law should be fixed and not repealed, which sets up the possibility that the controversial medical marijuana issue could go un-fixed this session.

“We’re playing a parlor game with people’s lives here,” adds Senator Wanzenried.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

nobody said on Saturday, Apr 2 at 1:22 PM

Christan women let me get this right. You would make the sick and suffering from pain because somebody else abuse the medical marijuana program. I say lets stop organized religion from preaching until the catholic church release the information to the scope of the abuse by the priests. The hiding of Nazis war criminals and last but least the torturing of children in Indian schools. I friend my age told me of children beat to death out in hays and lodge pole at catholic schools. Quit trying to push your idea of life on me and the other sick and poor, or else make all health care free.

Christian woman said on Friday, Apr 1 at 11:32 AM

I support repeal, if there can be no consensus on rewriting the law. From above comments our healthiest citizens from our two largest college towns are at the forefront of MM in users and caregivers. Until there is a way to curb the recreational use by getting into the MM program, then we are back to normal channels for our drugs.

Anonymous said on Friday, Apr 1 at 9:50 AM

I have MS. No, I am not currently a card holder but I do use pain pills regularly. I live with pain every single day and I am not even in my 40's yet. I think this should be an option for me once the pain pills just don't cut it anymore. I also believe there are a lot of people out there who are abusing it and without stricter laws, will ruin it for those of us it truly would benefit but our state is so scattered with Meth heads etc, do they truly believe taking away medical marijuana is going to solve the drug problem in our state?

Anonymous said on Friday, Apr 1 at 9:29 AM

How can they speak for the voters and say this is not what they wanted? How many voters are they speaking for? Not me for sure!! How many people overdosed from marijuana? Prescription pain medication is widely abused and we lose alot of our people to death from them due to overdose. Marijuana is not only used to smoke by the patients as most think, their are muscle rubs for the joint and muscle pain which works for arthritis. There are also baked goods and more items for ingestion that are all HERBAL AND NATURAL. So why discriminate the issue of medical marijuana when the prescription pain meds are out of hand. I am also discriminated against becuz i live on federal land and our funding comes from the federal govt so i cant hold a job and always in fear of getting arrested for using my medical marijuana so i have to go off the federal land to use my medical marijuana!! When will this discrimination issue be resolved?

1 of the 62% said on Friday, Apr 1 at 7:10 AM

I am dissappointed... how dare you play games with the peoples vote... You people are not God... my doctor, and myself, know what is right for ME. I keep hearing that this isn't what the voters wanted, back in 2004, WRONG.. This is exactly what my vote wanted...

nobody said on Friday, Apr 1 at 3:47 AM

It has just come in the paper today that out two of the top five healthiest countries Missoula and Gallatin counties both are at the for front of medical marijuana in the numbers using and caregivers. Here is one last thing the states that have medical marijuana use less prescription per person. than the states that do not have medical marijuana. Save Montana's by not repealing or replacing medical marijuana and stop the pills before they hit the street. I have been to a pain specialist doctor. I was told that I would be on pain pills and muscle relaxers and anti-inflammations medication the rest of my life. I have degenerative disc disease,degenerative arthritis in four lower discs, and carpal tunnel in both hands. I also have a torn en Meniscus that needs surgery and have been told by a knee specialist. I am one of then success of the medical marijuana act. I have also see the studies on the inter-net from Spain that show medical marijuana has four cannabises effects cancer

knowa said on Friday, Apr 1 at 2:08 AM

Last week the National Cancer Institute web site posted this phrase only to change it after a few days once the conflict of prohibition policy was noticed and changed it to one below it. This statement would change the scheduling from #1 to #3 I demand that the NCI stated the truth not the will of the DEA The potential benefits of medicinal Cannabis for people living with cancer include antiemetic effects, appetite stimulation, pain relief, and improved sleep. In the practice of integrative oncology, the health care provider may recommend medicinal Cannabis not only for symptom management but also for its possible direct antitumor effect. NCI apparently got a talking to from someone, because now that page has been scrubbed of any reference to the direct antitumoral effects of cannabis: The potential benefits of medicinal Cannabis for people living with cancer include antiemetic effects, appetite stimulation, pain relief, and improved sleep. Though no relevant surveys of practice

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

News, Sports, Weather for Great Falls, Helena, and all of Montana and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Icon
Great Falls Great Falls Intl Airport, MT
Current Temp 57.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Southwest at 8.1 MPH (7 KT)
Pressure : 1013.5 mb
Humidity : 53 %
Icon
Helena Helena Regional, MT
Current Temp 54.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Calm
Pressure : 1016.9 mb
Humidity : 55 %
More Weather
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

AP Video