Tools

Whitetail and Big Beaver Residents Say Controversial Port Worth Keeping

By KFBB News Team

It's been called "The Port to Nowhere" and "a border crossing that virtually no one wants or needs." But farmers and business owners in Whitetail say that isn't entirely true, and losing the crossing would be devastating to their community.

Newschannel 5's Stephanie Tyrpak had the chance to meet with many of the locals in both Montana and Canada, and follow them as they use the small border crossing as part of their daily routine.

"I've come through that port at Whitetail and Big Beaver as many as 225 times a year, " said farmer Lee Cook, who works land on both sides of the U.S. and Canadian border. "Sometimes I come through two or three times a day, depending on what I have to do to cover the needs of the farm."

And for the long-time farmers like Lee Cook, news that the small Whitetail Port could be shutdown has been frustrating.

"I'm out of business without this port," said Cook. "I'm going to have to figure out something different to do with my land. I can't retire yet, I just put two kids through college, and I have two more to go. I need that land for my livelihood."

The Whitetail Port has been at the center of controversy since last year when it was announced that the crossing, which sees an average of five cars a day, would be receiving over $8 million in stimulus funds for a remodel.

But in August, Canada announced plans to close their side of the port in April, and now there are increasing calls to close the U.S. side as well.

"I feel as a rural community, we're so tired of losing our assets," said James Hanson, a Whitetail farmer. "And it just seems like one thing after the other. Whether it's an elevator, or a post office, now it's our border."

If they lose the Whitetail Port, farmers and business owners would have to travel to the Scobey and Plentywood ports to reach land that now sits directly along one two-lane state road.

"It's gonna mean an extra 30 miles of trip, at 100 loads, that's 3000 extra miles, that's $15,000 that are going to come off the top of my operation," said Cook.

Town hall meetings with state and national leaders have been held to discuss the future of the Whitetail Port in Havre and Scobey. But Whitetail residents are still waiting for a meeting in their own town, and an opportunity for farmers on both sides of border to show just how connected and viable the communities of Whitetail and Big Beaver truly are.

"There's other businesses up here, fertilizer businesses and things, that slip 100s of thousands of dollars worth of material through that border," said Cook. "It's maybe not so many crossings in numbers, but it amounts to millions of dollars worth of trade."

"It's part of our local community," said Canadian farmer Warren Volke, who lives near Big Beaver. "I actually consider Whitetail to be part of our community, I've had a P.O. box there since 1985. I've been using it in commercial purposes. I usually go down once or twice a week."

And with fears of a lack of security, loss of local business, and a deteriorating road used to transport grain, residents are digging in for a long fight to keep their crossing.

"We have a thriving community here, and its just one more nail in the coffin for us," said Hanson. "And if we could just get some backing, and for people to understand that there is people left here, and there is people using that border and I think its viable to keep it open."

"We're not large in numbers out here, but we're fairly large in spirit," said Cook. "We've survived a lot of stuff out here, same as our neighbors up in Canada...You might as well put me in the ground, that's what it's gonna take."


You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Bordertown said on Saturday, Sep 25 at 6:37 AM

These farmers won't "lose their farm" if the ports close. There is the port of Scobey, which is 15 minutes - I repeat - FIFTEEN MINUTES West and the port of Raymond 25 minutes East. If they can't make that work, then they have the option of selling their land. I know for a fact that Mr. Cook has been talking about selling his land in Canada for YEARS. He made numerous mentions of doing this long before the ports said anything about the possibility of closing. Land is worth money - selling it is not going to put a man in the hole - it will leave him with a lot of cash to either put away for retirement, or purchase land South of the border.

Anonymous said on Friday, Sep 24 at 1:10 PM

It's easy to say shut the port if you don't need it or use it. But if you're going to lose your farm if it closes down, then this port means everything to you. Do these farmers just not matter?

Bordertown said on Friday, Sep 24 at 6:22 AM

"Local Yokel" has a good point - by having these ports open, you are wasting a tonne of money and even more so, the officer's time and knowledge. These people who protect our borders shouldn't have to sit around all day twiddling their thumbs. I'm sure that even when they get traffic/travellers through their crossing, they know 90% of them and therefore, there is nothing new for them to experience. No disrespect to the officers, but they probobly don't remember half of the stuff that they learned when they finished the training for their job, all because the port DOESN'T GET USED! Do you think that 3 measly little interviews are going to change the mind of the government? This isn't even news - let's find a real story to talk about and stop complaining about such small happeneings that make no impact on society. Shut the port down already.

Local Yokel said on Thursday, Sep 23 at 11:30 PM

These ports are a waste of tax payer's money. There are stats that prove that these ports go DAYS without seeing a single vehicle/traveller. The stats that are saying that they see between 2-10 travellers/day are only because [example] a family of 7 will travel through the port and all 7 travellers are recorded…even the 3 children under the age of 4 years old. The Governments are paying hundreds of thousands of dollars for the officers to sit around and lose the knowledge that they worked so hard to gain. They are also paying for the upkeep and maintainence of the two separate ports. As for the locals who are using this port for commercial purposes, I do not believe that these ports are designated for commercial imports/exports, so these locals are obviously breaking the law and not being truthful to officers when doing so. Suck it up, travel the extra miles, or sell your land! There are plenty of farmers in Canada that would be more than willing to buy your property.

eagletails said on Thursday, Sep 23 at 12:50 PM

I too as a north american indian that has relations on both sides of the 'medicine line'49 th parrell- been a crossing for my people and the farm communities always been watchful and nieghboly-sad it is all about a way of life disappearing to once a common way of freedom and life,

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

News, Sports, Weather for Great Falls, Helena, and all of Montana and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

Icon
Great Falls Great Falls Intl Airport, MT
Current Temp 57.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Southwest at 10.4 MPH (9 KT)
Pressure : 1013.7 mb
Humidity : 53 %
Icon
Helena Helena Regional, MT
Current Temp 53.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Calm
Pressure : 1016.9 mb
Humidity : 55 %
More Weather
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

AP Video