Doctors and Survivors Speak Out on a Mammogram Study - KFBB.com News, Sports and Weather

Doctors and Survivors Speak Out on a Study that Questions Mammograms

Posted: Updated:
Montana -

A new study on mammograms is igniting major controversy across the nation, questioning if we need mammograms after all?

Dr. Harrer, an oncologist/Medical Director of Benefis Breast Center, says, "Most clinicians adhere strongly to the American Cancer Societies guidelines that women, starting at the age of 40, should get annual mammograms."

But the study is suggesting differently. It analyzed 90,000 subjects for over a quarter century. One group got regular mammograms and the other only received physical breast exams. 25 years later, researches were shocked to find 500 deaths in the mammogram group and 505 in the other. Showing that those receiving mammograms were just as likely to die from breast cancer as those who did not.

The study also found that mammograms come with a 22% chance over diagnosis, causing many women to get unnecessary treatment.

One in eight women will develop breast cancer in a life time. Therefore, the big question now is what's the right thing to do and are the benefits worth the risk? Local doctors are saying this study should not be over interpreted.

Dr. Harrer explains, "That's one study, in the context of multiple other studies over the last 15 to 20 years. Everyone of those determined that there was either a significant benefit to doing mammography or a strong trend in that direction."

Dr. Harrer also says those who support the study think it should still be compiled with other research before a final consensus is made.

For survivors, like Patty Jaraczeski, this study certainly hits home. In 1993 she had repeated mammograms to investigate a suspicious mass, but test results determined it was normal breast tissue.

Four years later, a mammogram showed she had a mass in the same area, so doctors switched over to using an ultra sound. It was that ultra sound that diagnosed her with cancer. Not the mammogram. But even with her difficult story and this new studies results, its still not the mammograms she would have wanted to change.

She tells us, "I believe in mammograms. I believe it can be the first place to start. In hindsight, in 1993, I should have been more aware of my physical health and demanded some further tests, but at the time I didn't know any better."

She says her advice is not to ditch the mammogram, but instead, "I think we need to be in charge of our own medical health. If the doctors feel there's something suspicious, but its okay, we'll wait and see, those kinds of things, I think you need to take charge and say no. I want another test."

So while the research may be new, and the opinions on what is right may vary, for now multiple things remain the same. The need for mammograms, The need for more research and most importantly, the need to take charge. Don't be afraid to get the exam, and don't afraid to dig deeper.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • UPDATE: Fire at Silverwood caused by cigarette

    UPDATE: Fire at Silverwood caused by cigarette

    Friday, August 29 2014 2:35 PM EDT2014-08-29 18:35:38 GMT
    ATHOL, Idaho - After a thorough investigation into the fire that closed a portion of Silverwood Theme Park last weekend, investigators with the Timberlake Fire Protection District say it was most likely an improperly discarded cigarette that started the fire.
    ATHOL, Idaho - After a thorough investigation into the fire that closed a portion of Silverwood Theme Park last weekend, investigators with the Timberlake Fire Protection District say it was most likely an improperly discarded cigarette that started the fire. The fire happened on August 24th, around 2:00pm in a restroom at the Boulder Beach Water park. The water park was evacuated while crews worked to put the flames out. 
  • PHOTOS: Zombies In Downtown Spokane!

    PHOTOS: Zombies In Downtown Spokane!

    Wednesday, June 11 2014 10:45 AM EDT2014-06-11 14:45:30 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - In case you missed the first week of production for "Z Nation" in downtown Spokane, we wanted to share the photos we captured of the Zombies we could see lingering around, outside the KHQ station. Filming for the SyFy network's 'Z Nation' is underway! We sent our photographer Reed Schmitt over to the set to get up close and personal.
    SPOKANE, Wash. - In case you missed the first week of production for "Z Nation" in downtown Spokane, we wanted to share the photos we captured of the Zombies we could see lingering around, outside the KHQ station. Filming for the SyFy network's 'Z Nation' is underway! We sent our photographer Reed Schmitt over to the set to get up close and personal.
  • Mills Canyon burn out planned for Tuesday

    Mills Canyon burn out planned for Tuesday

    Tuesday, July 15 2014 12:58 PM EDT2014-07-15 16:58:49 GMT
    ENTIAT, Wash. - A burn out operation is planned for Tuesday morning in an effort to establish a secure line in the bottom of the canyon where the Mills Canyon Fire is burning. Burning material rolling downhill and igniting spot fires on the north side of Swakane Canyon have caused concerns and indicate a vulnerability to a fire escape and repeatedly expose firefighters to very steep terrain and rolling material.
    ENTIAT, Wash. - A burn out operation is planned for Tuesday morning in an effort to establish a secure line in the bottom of the canyon where the Mills Canyon Fire is burning. Burning material rolling downhill and igniting spot fires on the north side of Swakane Canyon have caused concerns and indicate a vulnerability to a fire escape and repeatedly expose firefighters to very steep terrain and rolling material.
  • Plane Crash Near Neihart

    Plane Crash Near Neihart

    Authorities say one person was killed when a single-engine plane crashed about 30 miles southeast of Great Falls.
    Authorities say one person was killed when a single-engine plane crashed about 30 miles southeast of Great Falls.
  • One Dies in Plane Crash Near Showdown

    One Dies in Plane Crash Near Showdown

    Emergency crews are on the scene of a plane crash just north of the Showdown ski areaIt happened earlier this afternoon just after 1pm near mile marker 30 on US Highway 89 near the Kings Hill recreation area in the Lewis and Clark National Forest. A Federal Aviation official says the plane had four people aboard but there was no immediate word on injuries. However Cascade County Sheriff Bob Edwards has told KFBB that there has been one fatality.There is also no word yet on what kind of plane ...
    Emergency crews are on the scene of a plane crash just north of the Showdown ski areaIt happened earlier this afternoon just after 1pm near mile marker 30 on US Highway 89 near the Kings Hill recreation area in the Lewis and Clark National Forest. A Federal Aviation official says the plane had four people aboard but there was no immediate word on injuries. However Cascade County Sheriff Bob Edwards has told KFBB that there has been one fatality.There is also no word yet on what kind of plane ...
  • Identity Revealed in Fatal

    Identity Revealed in Fatal

    The identity of the person killed in a car accident early on Saturday morning has been released.
    The identity of the person killed in a car accident early on Saturday morning has been released.
  • Governor Attends Labor Day Picnic

    Governor Attends Labor Day Picnic

    Monday at the Montana Expo Park was the Labor Day Picnic where local residents came to celebrate.
    Monday at the Montana Expo Park was the Labor Day Picnic where local residents came to celebrate.
Powered by WorldNow

Sports

  • Sports
  • Community

  • Community
  • Powered by WorldNow
    All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and Max Media. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.