Question of sealed documents arises in Robert Back case - KFBB.com News, Sports and Weather

Question of sealed documents arises in Robert Back case

Posted: Updated:

 UPDATE: Judge John Kutzman has ruled in favor of Robert Back, after a motion was made to file expert disclosure under seal. 

As a result, certain medical documents related to Robert Back's case against Benefis Health System will remain unavailable to the media and public. 

This recent development, of course, stems from the 2014 head injury Back received while playing high school football for Belt High School, which resulted in permanent damage. To read our previous coverage, click here.


Benefis Health System has responded to Robert Back's attorneys' motion to file expert disclosure under seal. In other words, Robert Back's attorneys requested in the midst of the discovery period to keep certain medical records sealed from the public; Benefis disagrees. 

In mid-October Benefis stated in court documents that they had not seen the Plaintiff's disclosure until October 10th, resulting in not enough of an opportunity to "review Plaintiffs' Expert Disclosure prior to the filing of the motion to evaluate whether Benefis agreed" that the information would be appropriate to seal. Benefis also states that it is interpreting the Plaintiffs' motion as a request to not only seal their expert disclosure, but also seal Benefis' expert disclosure.

Robert Back's party had filed the motion due to what they call "sensitive" healthcare information about Robert. 

But after reviewing that motion, Benefis states they do not find any information that would warrant sealing, in part because the Plaintiffs already detailed Robert's health status in the original complaint, which is of public record. Benefis says that information is also discussed in both parties' expert witness disclosures. In turn, court documents state Benefis does not see "anything unusual" in the disclosure that would warrant sealing. 

Benefis' lawyers also cite the Montana Constitution, which states, "No person shall be deprived of the right to examine documents or to observe the deliberations of all public bodies or agencies of state government and its subdivisions, except in cases in which the demand of individual privacy clearly exceeds the merits of public disclosure." "It is clear... that the public and the press have the right under state law to attend and observe with limited exception the hearings of the courts of the this state." State ex rel. Great Falls Tribune Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial Dist. Court, Cascade Cty.

According to administrative assistants, Judge John Kutzman has not yet made a decision as to whether the documents should be sealed. 

In the meantime, Benefis has filed an unopposed motion to extend the deadline to respond to the Plaintiffs' motion for sanctions; the new deadline, if approved, will be January 5th, 2018. 

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Search for 3 suspects after a double murder at Missoula's Mountain Valley Inn

    Search for 3 suspects after a double murder at Missoula's Mountain Valley Inn

    Friday, October 19 2018 12:19 PM EDT2018-10-19 16:19:05 GMT

    Authorities are searching for three suspects, after two people were found dead at Missoula's Mountain Valley hotel. The reports came in around 1 a.m. Friday morning. Authorities arrived at the inn on West Broadway St. and began investigating. They confirmed there was possible use of a firearm associated with the murders. They say they have found a car associated with the suspects, but have not released the identities of those suspects. Authorities say there is no threat to the ge...

    Authorities are searching for three suspects, after two people were found dead at Missoula's Mountain Valley hotel. The reports came in around 1 a.m. Friday morning. Authorities arrived at the inn on West Broadway St. and began investigating. They confirmed there was possible use of a firearm associated with the murders. They say they have found a car associated with the suspects, but have not released the identities of those suspects. Authorities say there is no threat to the ge...

  • Officers back to work hours after they were involved in a crash

    Officers back to work hours after they were involved in a crash

    Thursday, October 18 2018 6:21 PM EDT2018-10-18 22:21:47 GMT
    Thursday, October 18 2018 6:21 PM EDT2018-10-18 22:21:47 GMT
    One Lewis and Clark County patrol vehicle is out of commission after a driver, who was going the wrong way, rammed into the car. Two officers were traveling down Benton Avenue in Helena when they were hit yesterday afternoon. Neither the deputies nor the other driver involved are injured.However, the car did receive significant damage. Lewis and Clark County Sheriff Leo Dutton says they're in the process of getting that vehicle fixed, adding that accidents happen. ‘”Yo...
    One Lewis and Clark County patrol vehicle is out of commission after a driver, who was going the wrong way, rammed into the car. Two officers were traveling down Benton Avenue in Helena when they were hit yesterday afternoon. Neither the deputies nor the other driver involved are injured.However, the car did receive significant damage. Lewis and Clark County Sheriff Leo Dutton says they're in the process of getting that vehicle fixed, adding that accidents happen. ‘”Yo...
  • Presidential plane lands in Great Falls

    Presidential plane lands in Great Falls

    Thursday, October 18 2018 7:35 PM EDT2018-10-18 23:35:30 GMT
    Thursday, October 18 2018 7:35 PM EDT2018-10-18 23:35:30 GMT
    KFBB is receiving reports that a presidential plane has landed in Great Falls at the Montana Air National Guard. It is unclear what exactly the plane is doing at MANG, although it is suspected the plane could be apart of the President's fleet and there wasn't room at the Missoula International Airport for the entire fleet to land.  Our Ricky Blackburn is currently on the scene at the airport, and is working to bring us more information as it becomes available. 
    KFBB is receiving reports that a presidential plane has landed in Great Falls at the Montana Air National Guard. It is unclear what exactly the plane is doing at MANG, although it is suspected the plane could be apart of the President's fleet and there wasn't room at the Missoula International Airport for the entire fleet to land.  Our Ricky Blackburn is currently on the scene at the airport, and is working to bring us more information as it becomes available. 
  • Coeur d'Alene Police investigating school shooting threat made on Snapchat

    Coeur d'Alene Police investigating school shooting threat made on Snapchat

    Friday, October 19 2018 1:04 AM EDT2018-10-19 05:04:39 GMT

    COEUR D'ALENE, Idaho - Coeur d'Alene Police are investigating a reported school shooting threat at Coeur d'Alene High School. A spokesperson for the district said that the threat was written on a napkin and shared  on Snapchat. It says: "CHS school shooting 10-19-18. Be ready." Police tell us that while they are still investigating whether the threat is credible, they do not believe the CHS that the note mentions is referring to Coeur d'Alene High School.

    COEUR D'ALENE, Idaho - Coeur d'Alene Police are investigating a reported school shooting threat at Coeur d'Alene High School. A spokesperson for the district said that the threat was written on a napkin and shared  on Snapchat. It says: "CHS school shooting 10-19-18. Be ready." Police tell us that while they are still investigating whether the threat is credible, they do not believe the CHS that the note mentions is referring to Coeur d'Alene High School.

  • Angela Marshall interviews President Trump one-on-one after Missoula rally

    Angela Marshall interviews President Trump one-on-one after Missoula rally

    Friday, October 19 2018 12:31 AM EDT2018-10-19 04:31:36 GMT

    During Thursday's campaign rally in Missoula, ABC FOX Montana's Angela Marshall got the only opportunity to interview President Donald Trump.

    During Thursday's campaign rally in Missoula, ABC FOX Montana's Angela Marshall got the only opportunity to interview President Donald Trump.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Presidential plane lands in Great Falls

    Presidential plane lands in Great Falls

    Thursday, October 18 2018 7:35 PM EDT2018-10-18 23:35:30 GMT
    Thursday, October 18 2018 7:35 PM EDT2018-10-18 23:35:30 GMT
    KFBB is receiving reports that a presidential plane has landed in Great Falls at the Montana Air National Guard. It is unclear what exactly the plane is doing at MANG, although it is suspected the plane could be apart of the President's fleet and there wasn't room at the Missoula International Airport for the entire fleet to land.  Our Ricky Blackburn is currently on the scene at the airport, and is working to bring us more information as it becomes available. 
    KFBB is receiving reports that a presidential plane has landed in Great Falls at the Montana Air National Guard. It is unclear what exactly the plane is doing at MANG, although it is suspected the plane could be apart of the President's fleet and there wasn't room at the Missoula International Airport for the entire fleet to land.  Our Ricky Blackburn is currently on the scene at the airport, and is working to bring us more information as it becomes available. 
  • Company behind Black Butte Copper Mine facing campaign allegations

    Company behind Black Butte Copper Mine facing campaign allegations

    Wednesday, October 17 2018 5:24 PM EDT2018-10-17 21:24:27 GMT
    Wednesday, October 17 2018 5:52 PM EDT2018-10-17 21:52:59 GMT

    Sandfire Resources, the Australian-based company behind the Black Butte Copper Mine in White Sulphur Springs, is getting some heat tonight from proponents of Initiative 186. I-186 is a ballot initiative that would increase mining regulations, specifically with regards to water pollution.

    Sandfire Resources, the Australian-based company behind the Black Butte Copper Mine in White Sulphur Springs, is getting some heat tonight from proponents of Initiative 186. I-186 is a ballot initiative that would increase mining regulations, specifically with regards to water pollution.

  • Local band, L.A. bound

    Local band, L.A. bound

    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:49 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:49:44 GMT
    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:54 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:54:30 GMT

    GREAT FALLS- Five guys from Great Falls, one band, and a shot at recording in L.A. They're called Call Of The Awakened. They've been together since high school jamming out to hard rock and metal music, and now they're heading to L.A. in February for three weeks to record their second album. However, this journey didn't come easy. Besides the struggle of breaking into one of the toughest industries in the world, two members also dealt with major heartbreak.  "We were gettin...

    GREAT FALLS- Five guys from Great Falls, one band, and a shot at recording in L.A. They're called Call Of The Awakened. They've been together since high school jamming out to hard rock and metal music, and now they're heading to L.A. in February for three weeks to record their second album. However, this journey didn't come easy. Besides the struggle of breaking into one of the toughest industries in the world, two members also dealt with major heartbreak.  "We were gettin...

  • Bayern Brewery reaches out to Great Falls for glass recycling

    Bayern Brewery reaches out to Great Falls for glass recycling

    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:17 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:17:14 GMT
    Sunday, October 14 2018 7:22 PM EDT2018-10-14 23:22:40 GMT

    Jurgen Knoller, the CEO of Missoula's Bayern Brewing, leads the brewery's innovative recycling program and says he wants to start accepting glass from Great Falls.

    Jurgen Knoller, the CEO of Missoula's Bayern Brewing, leads the brewery's innovative recycling program and says he wants to start accepting glass from Great Falls.

Powered by Frankly
Copyright - All content © 2001 - 2018. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.