Plaintiffs claim Benefis athletic trainer should be held account - KFBB.com News, Sports and Weather

Plaintiffs claim Benefis athletic trainer should be held accountable in Robert Back case

Posted: Updated:

Attorneys for Robert Back, the high school football player who received substantial, permanent brain injuries while playing in a Belt High School football game in 2014, are now working to prove an athletic trainer employed through Benefis Health System should be held accountable for Back’s injuries.

On January 4th, Back’s attorneys filed a “Brief in Support of Motion for Determination of Law Regarding Licensed Health Care Professional.” According to court documents, the brief is a request for the “Court to determine as a matter of law that former defendant Jessica Hansen, ATC, an employee of Benefis, is a licensed health care professional under Dylan Steigers Protection of Youth Athletes Act.”

The brief goes on to state that despite Benefis continually arguing Hansen does not fall under the guidelines of the Act, she still was quoted in an email as stating Back was “ok concussion wise” to play in the football game which ultimately led to Back’s hospitalization. Back’s attorneys argue along with that email evidence, it is clear Hansen falls under the requirements of the Act to be held responsible.

Court documents also state one of the Plaintiffs’ experts, Head Athletic Trainer at the University of Montana, J.C. Weida, agrees that Hansen’s title as an athletic trainer is included under the Act’s broader title of “licensed health care professional.”

In addition to arguing Hansen does, in fact, fall under the Protection of Youth Athletes Act, Plaintiffs’ attorney also filed a “Brief in Support of Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings-Affirmative Defenses of Assumption of Risk,” on January 5th.

In this Brief, the Plaintiffs argue both Benefis Health System and Hansen do not fall under the Montana Recreation Responsibility Act, which, according to court documents, provides an assumption of risk defense only to providers of recreational activities: 1) A person who participates in any sport or recreational opportunity assumes the inherent risks in that sport or recreational opportunity, whether those risks are known or unknown, and is legally responsible for all injury or death to the person and for all damage to the person’s property that result from the inherent risks in that sport or recreational opportunity, and 2) a provider is not required to eliminate, alter, or control the inherent risks within the particular sport or recreational opportunity that is provided.

In last week’s Brief, the Plaintiffs state because Benefis is not a provider of the recreational activity, it is not entitled to protections afforded by the act.

To see previous coverage of the Robert Back v. Benefis case, click here. Jury Trial is scheduled to begin March 5th, 2018.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Helena Woman Dies in Crash

    Helena Woman Dies in Crash

    Monday, January 22 2018 10:52 AM EST2018-01-22 15:52:48 GMT
    The Montana Highway Patrol says a 25-year-old woman has died in a single-vehicle crash north of Helena.    The patrol identified the victim as Kassandra Biller, of Helena, who was the only person in the vehicle.    The crash was reported around noon Saturday.    The patrol says the vehicle Biller was driving failed to negotiate a curve and went off the road. The vehicle struck several trees and rolled at least three times.    Biller was pronounc...
    The Montana Highway Patrol says a 25-year-old woman has died in a single-vehicle crash north of Helena.    The patrol identified the victim as Kassandra Biller, of Helena, who was the only person in the vehicle.    The crash was reported around noon Saturday.    The patrol says the vehicle Biller was driving failed to negotiate a curve and went off the road. The vehicle struck several trees and rolled at least three times.    Biller was pronounc...
  • Great Falls Police Department responds to separate stabbings

    Great Falls Police Department responds to separate stabbings

    Sunday, January 21 2018 11:48 PM EST2018-01-22 04:48:24 GMT
    Great Falls Police Officers responded to two separate stabbings. The first happened on Saturday. Officers say the victim was taken to the hospital, but no more information was released. The second stabbing happened on Sunday. Again, no information was released. GFPD says the stabbings are unrelated, but they are both under investigation.
    Great Falls Police Officers responded to two separate stabbings. The first happened on Saturday. Officers say the victim was taken to the hospital, but no more information was released. The second stabbing happened on Sunday. Again, no information was released. GFPD says the stabbings are unrelated, but they are both under investigation.
  • 3 arrested for Sunday morning assault

    3 arrested for Sunday morning assault

    Sunday, January 21 2018 10:44 PM EST2018-01-22 03:44:39 GMT
    A woman is recovering after being assaulted in her own home in Great Falls; now at least 3 people have been arrested in connection with the crime. GFPD says officers responded to a general disturbance call near 6th Avenue North Sunday morning. When they arrived, the victim told them several people broken into her home and beat her. Officers were able to find the suspect at the Great Falls Clinic and identified her as Vallerie Quinonez. Quinonez admitted she and several other people ha...
    A woman is recovering after being assaulted in her own home in Great Falls; now at least 3 people have been arrested in connection with the crime. GFPD says officers responded to a general disturbance call near 6th Avenue North Sunday morning. When they arrived, the victim told them several people broken into her home and beat her. Officers were able to find the suspect at the Great Falls Clinic and identified her as Vallerie Quinonez. Quinonez admitted she and several other people ha...
  • Access Fitness gets new technology to ensure a clean gym

    Access Fitness gets new technology to ensure a clean gym

    Sunday, January 21 2018 7:41 PM EST2018-01-22 00:41:00 GMT
    It’s the height of flu season in the US, and several high traffic areas, like gyms, could be one place where the virus could easily spread One local gym is taking extra precautions to make sure you stay healthy while working out. Access Fitness does daily cleaning routines which include wiping down machines, cleaning all towels and much more. But there are some things you can do to help keep the gym clean as well. “We actually have sanitizing spray that you can u...
    It’s the height of flu season in the US, and several high traffic areas, like gyms, could be one place where the virus could easily spread One local gym is taking extra precautions to make sure you stay healthy while working out. Access Fitness does daily cleaning routines which include wiping down machines, cleaning all towels and much more. But there are some things you can do to help keep the gym clean as well. “We actually have sanitizing spray that you can u...
  • Bozeman Fire wants to lower speed limit on Interstate

    Bozeman Fire wants to lower speed limit on Interstate

    Monday, January 22 2018 6:29 AM EST2018-01-22 11:29:14 GMT

    Bozeman Fire Officials are taking a stand to seek lower speed limits along I-90

    Bozeman Fire Officials are taking a stand to seek lower speed limits along I-90

  • NewsMore>>

  • Helena Woman Dies in Crash

    Helena Woman Dies in Crash

    Monday, January 22 2018 10:52 AM EST2018-01-22 15:52:48 GMT
    The Montana Highway Patrol says a 25-year-old woman has died in a single-vehicle crash north of Helena.    The patrol identified the victim as Kassandra Biller, of Helena, who was the only person in the vehicle.    The crash was reported around noon Saturday.    The patrol says the vehicle Biller was driving failed to negotiate a curve and went off the road. The vehicle struck several trees and rolled at least three times.    Biller was pronounc...
    The Montana Highway Patrol says a 25-year-old woman has died in a single-vehicle crash north of Helena.    The patrol identified the victim as Kassandra Biller, of Helena, who was the only person in the vehicle.    The crash was reported around noon Saturday.    The patrol says the vehicle Biller was driving failed to negotiate a curve and went off the road. The vehicle struck several trees and rolled at least three times.    Biller was pronounc...
  • Despite threats, Capitol workers feel safe

    Despite threats, Capitol workers feel safe

    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:37 PM EST2018-01-19 00:37:52 GMT
    HELENA, Mont.- A major threat to the state capitol as a man is taken into custody after telling police he was planning to "shoot up" the building.  Police say he may have been on his way to the capitol when he was caught. On Tuesday, the man told officers he planned to shoot up the Capitol the next day. Teams in Bozeman and Helena worked together to identify the suspect-- a 40-year-old Belgrade man. Yesterday they learned he had left Belgrade on his way to Helena. H...
    HELENA, Mont.- A major threat to the state capitol as a man is taken into custody after telling police he was planning to "shoot up" the building.  Police say he may have been on his way to the capitol when he was caught. On Tuesday, the man told officers he planned to shoot up the Capitol the next day. Teams in Bozeman and Helena worked together to identify the suspect-- a 40-year-old Belgrade man. Yesterday they learned he had left Belgrade on his way to Helena. H...
  • Update: Fatal crashed reported in Pondera County

    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:35 PM EST2018-01-19 00:35:27 GMT

    Montana Highway Patrol responded to a fatal vehicle accident Tuesday morning in Pondera County near the Heart Butte area. The accident took place on Heart Butte Road right in front of the U.S. Postal Office. The call came in over dispatch about 5:30 a.m. and took MHP troopers almost two hours to respond to the scene. Right now it is unclear what caused the accident or if anyone else was hurt or killed. We are working to find out more details.

    Montana Highway Patrol responded to a fatal vehicle accident Tuesday morning in Pondera County near the Heart Butte area. The accident took place on Heart Butte Road right in front of the U.S. Postal Office. The call came in over dispatch about 5:30 a.m. and took MHP troopers almost two hours to respond to the scene. Right now it is unclear what caused the accident or if anyone else was hurt or killed. We are working to find out more details.

  • MAGIE expo is here in the Electric City

    MAGIE expo is here in the Electric City

    Thursday, January 18 2018 7:16 PM EST2018-01-19 00:16:40 GMT
    Its that time of year Again for those who are looking to buy that new tractor they have been eying all year or just to get some financial advice for anything Ag-related and MAGIE is the place to be. Thursday kicked off the event at the Montana Expo Park is where you can talk to over 300 vendors selling everything from handheld tools all the way to monster truck sized tractors. This year is the opportunity for farmers, ranchers or just people who love agriculture, to learn about the n...
    Its that time of year Again for those who are looking to buy that new tractor they have been eying all year or just to get some financial advice for anything Ag-related and MAGIE is the place to be. Thursday kicked off the event at the Montana Expo Park is where you can talk to over 300 vendors selling everything from handheld tools all the way to monster truck sized tractors. This year is the opportunity for farmers, ranchers or just people who love agriculture, to learn about the n...
Powered by Frankly
Copyright - All content © 2001 - 2018. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.