President Trump's rally results in priest controversy - KFBB.com News, Sports and Weather

President Trump's rally results in priest controversy

Posted: Updated:

GREAT FALLS- The aftermath of President Trump's rally on July 5 created a stir on social media about four Catholic priests who attended the rally and sat near the front row.

The priests were observed clapping along when President Trump mocked the #MeToo movement. The Helena Independent Record reported that their appearance may have violated some ethical rules for clergy.

Francis Xavier Porter, a Ursuline Nun, knows two of the four priests: Father Garrett Nelson, and Father Ryan Erlenbush, who are from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Great Falls-Billings.  She says they should have been taught not to get involved in politics.

“Two priests that I knew or I know are young, and their training is much more recent than mine. and I'm much older. And as we've been educated out of religion, as all religions were taught not to be involved in anything political,” said Porter. 

Father Garrett, a priest at Corpus Cristi Parish, said he was not able to comment.

He says comments will be handled by the Bishop of Great Falls-Billings, Michael William Warfel who released the following statement to the Independent Record:

"While they are free to support a political candidate — and I believe they were there in support of Matt Rosendale, who is running for the Senate seat from Montana — they should not have been attired in clerical garb and seated in such a prominent location. I myself had been invited to attend the rally but declined. It has been my experience that people can be manipulated and used unwittingly. I judge that it was an imprudent decision on their parts to allow themselves to be used in such a way though I suspect they had not thought of this. In Christ, Bishop Warfel," said Warfel.

"Well, I'd like to think they made a mistake and didn't realize they were getting into something like they did," said Porter. 

We reached out to Father Ryan Erlenbush, and Bishop Warfel's office, but we have not heard back from them as of news time. 

According to the Independent Record, in April 2011, Montana Catholic Conference made a statement saying religious leaders should avoid taking positions on candidates or participating in political party matters while acting in their individual capacity.

  • Most Popular

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Missing Great Falls woman found safe

    Missing Great Falls woman found safe

    Tuesday, November 13 2018 10:44 PM EST2018-11-14 03:44:21 GMT
    Tuesday, November 13 2018 11:51 PM EST2018-11-14 04:51:41 GMT

    The Great Falls Police Department is looking for a missing 79-year-old woman named Nadine.  Nadine suffers from dementia, and police say she wandered away from her home on the 1100 block of 1st Avenue South sometime around 4:00 Tuesday afternoon.  Nadine is described as Caucasian, with blonde hair, blue eyes, and about five feet tall. Nadine weighs around 85 pounds, and was last seen wearing green scrubs, a bright pink parka, and possibly gray sweatpants.  If you see...

    The Great Falls Police Department is looking for a missing 79-year-old woman named Nadine.  Nadine suffers from dementia, and police say she wandered away from her home on the 1100 block of 1st Avenue South sometime around 4:00 Tuesday afternoon.  Nadine is described as Caucasian, with blonde hair, blue eyes, and about five feet tall. Nadine weighs around 85 pounds, and was last seen wearing green scrubs, a bright pink parka, and possibly gray sweatpants.  If you see...

  • UPDATE: 3 suspects arrested in Idaho after Jefferson Co. Deputy was shot at

    UPDATE: 3 suspects arrested in Idaho after Jefferson Co. Deputy was shot at

    Tuesday, November 13 2018 7:59 PM EST2018-11-14 00:59:26 GMT
    Thursday, November 15 2018 7:44 PM EST2018-11-16 00:44:55 GMT
    Kolby SchmidtKolby Schmidt

    Jefferson County Sheriff's Department says 2 more people have been arrested and identified in relation to Tuesday's shooting. 

    Jefferson County Sheriff's Department says 2 more people have been arrested and identified in relation to Tuesday's shooting. 

  • From Coaching to Prison: Former Cats addresses Demons

    From Coaching to Prison: Former Cats addresses Demons

    Friday, November 16 2018 12:29 AM EST2018-11-16 05:29:59 GMT
    Friday, November 16 2018 12:57 AM EST2018-11-16 05:57:21 GMT

    Joe O’Brien’s story has been shared from local news all the way to ESPN. “Definitely a drug addict and alcoholic,” O’Brien said.    Once a promising assistant coach at Montana State University he was fired after being convicted of drug trafficking and money laundering and sentenced to prison. “Everyday above ground is a good one,” he said. After his release, he was given another chance at coaching, volunteering at Simms High, s...

    Joe O’Brien’s story has been shared from local news all the way to ESPN. “Definitely a drug addict and alcoholic,” O’Brien said.    Once a promising assistant coach at Montana State University he was fired after being convicted of drug trafficking and money laundering and sentenced to prison. “Everyday above ground is a good one,” he said. After his release, he was given another chance at coaching, volunteering at Simms High, s...

  • Animal shelters across the state need your help

    Animal shelters across the state need your help

    Thursday, November 15 2018 9:47 AM EST2018-11-15 14:47:53 GMT
    Montana is facing a major overcrowding issue in animal shelters across the state.  With every shelter at max capacity, if not more, animal shelters are forced to make room wherever possible. The main culprits of the overcrowding are cats, however, dogs are also part of the equation. Typically, Great Falls Animal Shelter sees an influx increase in the summers, but this year, they’ve seen more than usual. The Great Falls Animal Shelter typically has a cutoff of aroun...
    Montana is facing a major overcrowding issue in animal shelters across the state.  With every shelter at max capacity, if not more, animal shelters are forced to make room wherever possible. The main culprits of the overcrowding are cats, however, dogs are also part of the equation. Typically, Great Falls Animal Shelter sees an influx increase in the summers, but this year, they’ve seen more than usual. The Great Falls Animal Shelter typically has a cutoff of aroun...
  • Our Apologies

    The page you requested is currently unavailable. Pages on this site are constantly being revised, updated, and occasionally removed. You may have followed an outdated link or have outdated pages in your

    You have reached a page which is currently unavailable. We apologize for any inconvenience. Please use your browser's BACK button to return to the previous page

  • NewsMore>>

  • UPDATE: 3 suspects arrested in Idaho after Jefferson Co. Deputy was shot at

    UPDATE: 3 suspects arrested in Idaho after Jefferson Co. Deputy was shot at

    Tuesday, November 13 2018 7:59 PM EST2018-11-14 00:59:26 GMT
    Thursday, November 15 2018 7:44 PM EST2018-11-16 00:44:55 GMT
    Kolby SchmidtKolby Schmidt

    Jefferson County Sheriff's Department says 2 more people have been arrested and identified in relation to Tuesday's shooting. 

    Jefferson County Sheriff's Department says 2 more people have been arrested and identified in relation to Tuesday's shooting. 

  • Pursuit follows after shots fired in Sanders County

    Pursuit follows after shots fired in Sanders County

    Wednesday, November 14 2018 11:51 PM EST2018-11-15 04:51:02 GMT

    The Sanders County Sheriff's Office is reporting that deputies are actively pursuing suspects after gunshots were fired in the Trout Creek area.

    The Sanders County Sheriff's Office is reporting that deputies are actively pursuing suspects after gunshots were fired in the Trout Creek area.

  • Malmstrom commander relieved of duty

    Malmstrom commander relieved of duty

    Tuesday, November 13 2018 5:56 PM EST2018-11-13 22:56:59 GMT
    Tuesday, November 13 2018 6:07 PM EST2018-11-13 23:07:17 GMT

    MALMSTROM AFB - Lieutenant Colonel Raymond Fortner, the commander of the 741st Missile Security Forces Squadron, has been relieved of duty.  According to a press release from MAFB Public Affairs, Colonel Aaron Guill relieved Fortner due to,  "loss of trust and confidence after a series of events."   Complaints had been filed with the 341st Missile Wing Inspector General, which is what initiated an investigation.  It concluded several of those complaints ...

    MALMSTROM AFB - Lieutenant Colonel Raymond Fortner, the commander of the 741st Missile Security Forces Squadron, has been relieved of duty.  According to a press release from MAFB Public Affairs, Colonel Aaron Guill relieved Fortner due to,  "loss of trust and confidence after a series of events."   Complaints had been filed with the 341st Missile Wing Inspector General, which is what initiated an investigation.  It concluded several of those complaints ...

  • Pita Pit is officially open once again

    Pita Pit is officially open once again

    Tuesday, November 13 2018 1:31 PM EST2018-11-13 18:31:34 GMT
    Tuesday, November 13 2018 1:31 PM EST2018-11-13 18:31:34 GMT
    Less than a month ago, 25-year-old Allen Roberts was arrested on 18 charges after crashing into a Pita Pit in Great Falls on 10th Ave. S.  What originally was supposed to take a week turned into several as store manager Christine Rattlingtail repaired severe damages and revamped the store.  Today, the Pita Pit is finally RE-opening their doors with a newly renovated interior.  Robert's arraignment is scheduled for Thursday, November 15th, at 2 pm. 
    Less than a month ago, 25-year-old Allen Roberts was arrested on 18 charges after crashing into a Pita Pit in Great Falls on 10th Ave. S.  What originally was supposed to take a week turned into several as store manager Christine Rattlingtail repaired severe damages and revamped the store.  Today, the Pita Pit is finally RE-opening their doors with a newly renovated interior.  Robert's arraignment is scheduled for Thursday, November 15th, at 2 pm. 
Powered by Frankly
Copyright - All content © 2001 - 2018. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, Terms of Service, and Ad Choices.